They needed to win and hope that Sheffield lost, or in an even more unlikely scenario that Ossett United lost and a significant goal difference would be overturned.
Tadcaster did their bit, Paddy Miller scoring a hat-trick as they led 4-1 at the break and 8-1 after 66 minutes, before it became clear it wasn’t to be their day, the game eventually finishing 8-3.
Because elsewhere, Sheffield had done enough to get the point they needed away at Brighouse Town, winning 2-1 thanks to Luke Rawson’s injury-time strike.
Ossett United finished fifth after they were held to a 1-1 draw at Stocksbridge Park Steels.
Gresley will go down to step five after they were beaten 3-0 by Pontefract Collieries, meaning Carlton Town survive with a reprieve owing to AFC Mansfield’s resignation, despite their 4-0 defeat to Marske United.
AFC Mansfield finished their season with a 2-1 win at home to Frickley Athletic, which sees them finish in a credible 15th place, while Belper Town and Spalding United finished goalless.
Scott Vernon’s hat-trick fired Cleethorpes Town to a 6-0 win at home to Stamford, Loughborough Dynamo came from behind to beat Pickering Town 5-1 and champions Morpeth Town won 1-0 at Wisbech.
To view all the results from the weekend’s games, visit the EVO-STIK League results page, and check the latest league tables here.
Keep up-to-date with our exclusive email newsletters.
Subscribe