Stocksbridge Park Steels was created in 1986 with the merger of Stocksbridge Works FC and another Stocksbridge club, Oxley Park Sports FC. It made sense. Stocksbridge Works had the ground and only one team and Oxley Park had three teams and no ground.

In the early years 1986-91 the new club ploughed all its resources into the Bracken Moor Stadium so as to meet ground grading criteria and enable the club to rise through the Non-League pyramid system. There was an opening of a social club, refurbishment to the dressing rooms, erection of floodlights, the building of new stand and extension to the social club new canteen area, making the ground the best junior stadium in South Yorkshire, which currently hosts 8 to 9 Sheffield and Hallamshire County FA Finals.

The appointment of Mick Horne and Trevor Gough as team manager and assistant in February 1991 heralded a period of success to rival the works in the 1950-1964 period. Under Mick and Trevor, Steels started their run to the present Unibond League. 1993-4 saw steels win Premier division of the NCEL, but Steels celebrations were cut short when the ground improvements necessitated were not at an advanced enough state to allow Steels to take place in the Unibond League. The following season Steels finished in 3rd place and in 1995-96 they were runners up to Hatfield Main and gained promotion to the Unibond First Division.

Steels made steady progress in the first five seasons in the Unibond League, with the highest placed position of 4th achieved in 2000-01. In 2002 Wayne Biggins was subsequently appointed player-manager after a short spell as assistant manager, with Graham Furness as assistant. In the 2002-03 season, Paul Jackson, equalled an FA Cup record of ten goals in one game, during the Steels 17-1 thrashing of Oldham Town.

Steels had their best FA Cup run in the 2003-2004 season, reaching the fourth qualifying round before eventually losing away at Shildon. In November 2003 Peter Rinkcavage was appointed as manager from Gainsborough Trinity with Paul Bradshaw as assistant with Jason Maybury, taking over from Bradshaw in 2004. A good season followed in 2005-2006 with the Steels just missing out on promotion after losing to Kendal in the play-offs.

In the 200-2007 season Steels missed out on a play-off position after being in the top three in 90 per cent of the season. But the team finished on a high note, beating local rivals Worksop Town in the Sheffield senior cup final at Hillsborough. his was to be the last game with Peter Rinkcavage in charge. He along with assistant Jason Maybury, left to join Worksop Town in the summer of 2007.

Gary Marrow, along with his assistant Mark Ogley was appointed manager before the start of the 2007-2008 season, with former player Gary Ingham taking over from Ogley midway through the season. In his first season at the club, Marrow steered them to a credible 5th place before losing to local rivals Sheffield FC in the play-off semi-final.

Steels have just been awarded the prestigious top FA Charter Standard Community Club Award (3 of 3) and representatives from most of the club's 22 squads were at the presentation on August 6th when Sheffield United player Geoff Horsfield and Blades legend Keith Edwards handed over the FA plaque. At the moment the club has 420 players either playing in a squad or being coached on a regular basis (12 Junior Boys, 3 Junior Girls and 7 Seniors). Stocksbridge Park Steels is now acknowledged to be the top 'grass roots' Community Club in South Yorkshire.

2008-09 was a fabulous season for Gary Marrows team, having finished third in Unibond League Division 1 South they won the play-off final against Derbyshire rivals Belper Town 1-0 and were promoted to the Unibond Premier League for the first time in the club’s history. Steels supporters were in for a roller coaster debut season in the Unibond Premier - 10 games into the season with his team top of the league, manager Gary Marrow resigned. Former Steels player Simon Collins took over but unfortunately his tenure didn’t last long. Reserve manager Steve Shutt then stepped up and guided Steels to an excellent 11th place.

The 2010-11 season started with the return of Gary Marrow as manager but he resigned just before Christmas during the 2011-12 season and was replaced with Chris Willcock, Darren Schofield appointed his assistant. Willcock guided the Steels to safety that season with a little help from Mickleover Sports who were docked points for playing an ineligible player. Willcock's second season in charge didn't start well and he was replaced by his assistant Darren Schofield who brought in the experienced defender Brett Lovell as his number two. Once again Stocksbridge managed to avoid relegation but again it went down to the wire.

The 2013-14 season started on a high with an exciting victory over Droylsden but from then on the Steels struggled, spending most of the season in the relegation zone. The club and long serving player-manager Darren Schofield parted company at the end of the season. Former Worsborough Bridge manager Chris Hilton was appointed the new boss for the 2014-15 season. Chris immediately brought in the former Emley midfielder Mark 'Willy' Wilson as his assistant and experienced former Barnsley defender Ryan Laight as player coach.

After a season mainly of consolidation, Hilton started his second season in charge with a change of assistant. Ryan Laight stepping up replacing Mark Wilson. Lee Thompson became the new player coach. 2015-16 was a successful season for Stocksbridge having their best ever run in the FA trophy before eventually losing out to National side Gateshead. This was after they had beaten the holders North Ferriby in the previous round. Steels finished the league in sixth place just a couple of points behind the play-off positions and manager Chris Hilton was rewarded with a contract for the next two years.

Season 2016-17 saw The Steels finish fourth in the league, along with another good run in the FA Trophy. Unfortunately, Stocksbridge were beaten in the play-off semi-finals, losing to Spalding United. The 2017-18 season started with manager Chris Hilton signing a new contract. The experienced Lee Thompson also became joint player-assistant manager with Ryan Laight.

The new 2018-19 season started with manager Chris Hilton signing a contract to stay with the club for the whole of the campaign. But big changes we're just about to happen - Allen Bethell, who had been the chairman since the club's formation in 1986 - announcing he was going to retire due to health reasons. Graham Furniss, who had been at the club for over 20 years in different roles including assistant manager, stepped up to the chairman's job with Roger Gissing becoming the vice-chairman.